Methods of hysterectomy

Published in

Adam Magos, Lynne Chapman, Vasiliki Varela, Pangiotis Papalampros, Pietro Gambadauro and Ramesan Navaratnarajah
University Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Royal Free Hospital, London NW3 2QG, UK
07 July 2005 bmj.com Rapid Responses for Johnson et al., 2005, 330 (7506):1478
EDITOR – We read the systematic review by Johnson et al on methods of hysterectomy with interest [1]. There has long been a debate amongst gynaecologists about which is the best route of surgery, but it is only with the advent of laparoscopic hysterectomy and its variants that proper scientific methods have been applied to compare different techniques. As the review makes clear, the medical literature is now extensive, and sufficient to answer most issues. We agree with the conclusion that vaginal hysterectomy should be the default route of surgery unless there are obvious contra-indications. Amongst all the careful science, it is a pity that the authors have allowed a statement to creep into their otherwise excellent article which is not backed up by fact. After stating that “vaginal hysterectomy is preferable to abdominal hysterectomy, provided it can be done safely”, they add “a laparoscopic approach may be appropriate if an oophorectomy is needed”, the implication being that oophorectomy is better done laparoscopically. This is simply not the case.